Malaysia’s FAA Safety Rating Downgraded

Malaysia has had its air safety rating downgraded by the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) to a category 2. The FAA released a statement on Monday confirming the change. This will prevent the country’s airlines from operating new routes to the US and will impose additional inspections on Malaysian airlines at US airports.

Malaysian Airlines Aircraft on runway
Malaysia has had its FAA safety rating downgraded to a category 2. Photo: [email protected] via Flickr

In a press statement, the FAA confirmed that Malaysia has lost its category 1 safety rating and will no longer be able to open new routes or increase existing services to the United States. Malaysian airlines will also be subjected to additional checks at US airports.

The statement from the FAA noted that the Civil Aviation Authority of Malaysia “is deficient in one or more areas, such as technical expertise, trained personnel, record-keeping, and/or inspection procedures”. The statement does not clarify in which area Malaysia has failed the FAA criteria.

Advertisement

What is the FAA safety rating?

According to the International Convention of Civil Aviation, every country is responsible for performing checks and regulating its own airlines. However, sometimes there is a need for extra checks to ensure each country is consistently and effectively managing its carriers. The FAA conducts an International Aviation Safety Assessment Program to ensure international standards are upheld.

Advertisement

A category 1 rating means the FAA is confident that any airlines from the country in question are being properly governed by the nation’s government. Therefore, the airlines may continue current service to the US, initiate new routes and partake in reciprocal codesharing agreements with US airlines.

Air Asia Malaysia
All Malaysian airlines will now have to undergo extra inspections at US airports. Photo: AirAsia

A category 2 rating does not mean that airlines from the country are unsafe or dangerous. In its statement today the FAA clarified that this is “an assessment of CAAM [Civil Aviation Authority of Malaysia] and not any individual airline operating inside or outside of Malaysia.”

Advertisement

However, it does suggest that the FAA does not believe the Malaysian government is able to manage and govern its airlines in a way that ensures a standard level of safety. Malaysian airlines will no longer be able to open new routes or expanding existing ones and codesharing agreements will cease. Malaysian airlines will also have to undergo additional checks at US airports.

Who does this affect?

Currently, the only Malaysian airline to fly to the United States is AirAsia from Kuala Lumpur to Honolulu, Hawaii. This flight will now be subjected to further inspections. Recent talk of Air Asia looking to expand its services to add more flights to the US will now have to wait until the category 1 rating is restored.

American Airlines codeshares with Malaysian Airlines, and will now have to cease this cooperation according to FAA regulations.

Air Asia X aircraft at terminal
Air Asia X was hoping to open a new route to California. Photo: 9M-XXZ via Flickr

Category 2 countries

Malaysia is not alone in having a category 2 rating; neighboring Thailand is also a category 2 as are Bangladesh, Costa Rica, Curacao and Ghana. While the category 2 rating is certainly a hindrance to Malaysian airlines opening new routes to the US, it is not a permanent death sentence.

Both Indonesia and Vietnam have gained category 1 status in recent years. Malaysia has been a category 1 country since 2003 so will no doubt be keen to ensure it returns to the category 1 rating.

Let us know what you think about Malaysia losing its category 1 status. Have you got concerns about the standard of safety in Malaysian aviation? Let us know in the comments.

Advertisement

10
Leave a Reply

6 Comment threads
4 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
9 Comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Cahpek

Malaysia AIrlines has been an airline version of “Dead Man Walking” for a while, and this downgrade by the US authorities merely adds another nail to the proverbial coffin. To think this one step further, could this action be due to other issues and it was not against Malaysia Airlines at all? Some suspicious individuals may argue (albeit without any proof whatsoever) this is a “ploy” not against Malaysia Airlines but against the AirAsia Group. Malaysia Airlines just happened to be in the “firing line”. Has some powerful people within the US airline industry see the start of AirAsiaX “incursion”… Read more »

Vince

Indeed coincidentally the 2 nations that recently got uplifted to category one happened to be the home country for large B737max operators. And coincidentally Thailand and Malaysia has not purchased any new boeing planes in recent years.
If this is not political lobbying I don’t know what is…

JFP

That’s why the 737MAX will never fly again in Europe…

kris o

This is rich coming from a governing body who couldn’t be arsed with proper inspections of an Aircraft and simple employed the manufacturer to sign off on its own accord.
Think they need to get their own house in order before pointing fingers at expert levels and the like…

Pao R. T.

So is that why they gave VIETNAM Category 1 status (and therefore paving the way for Vietnam Airlines to start flying to SFO and potentially partnering with Delta to extend their reach)?

Aussieinasia

A bit of the pot calling the kettle black ? FAA and Boeing !

Phil

Coming from the same FAA that allowed the death trap 737MAX to be certified I wouldn’t buy it!

Roger Wilco

The FAA allowed Boeing to self regulate. And like most corporations that lobby our government for such things, s*** almost always goes sideways.

Roger Wilco

LCC’s in the ASEAN region tend to cuts costs. In most cases a basic multi-engine rating is NOT required for A-320 FO’s. They’ll do C-172 private, instrument, and commercial (yes w/o the RG), and then they go straight to the A-320 level D sim. 250 hrs (total time) was a typical number for most of my brand new FO’s that I flew with in the Philippines. Japan LCC’s by comparison have their cadets do about 2 years of training after they’ve graduated college with a full set of ratings similar to the US including the multi-engine commercial instrument rating. I… Read more »

Bryan

Politics aside..

FAA: Downgrades Malaysia to Cat.2 status.
Also FAA: Certifies air worthiness of the 737MAX

Just saying